Homes for Sale in Waverly Hills, Tallahassee, Florida | Coldwell Banker Hartung, Inc., REALTORS

Waverly Hills Tallahassee

Waverly Hills is a Northeast Tallahassee neighborhood located in the midtown area. Located just off of Thomasville Road, homes tend to sell very quickly, due to the community’s prime location, gorgeous landscaping, and .5+ acre lots.

Waverly Hills Tallahassee

Waverly Hills Tallahassee FLYears ago, Waverly Hills was once a 400-acre hunting and fishing plantation. Now as a neighborhood, residents appreciate the beauty that surrounds them... sprawling live oaks draped with Spanish moss, bubbling streams, and, at the entrance, the Waverly Pond water feature - complete with a gazebo, porch swing, and a bridge over the water. The Waverly Hills neighborhood is the epitome of Southern charm.


The neighborhood has an active homeowners association, with events and get-togethers throughout the year, including potlucks, ice cream socials, and even the occasional movie night. Residents also get to take advantage of the Little Free Library, where people can trade books using the honor system. 

Waverly Hills Tallahassee Homes for Sale

The majority of the 300+ homes in the Waverly Hills community were built in the 1960s and 1970s. As such, you’ll find a mixture of midcentury modern as well as the more traditional, southern farmhouse-style homes. 


The houses are typically 2,000 to 3,000 sq. ft. with 3 or 4 bedrooms. Prices range from $300,000 to $400,000. At this price point, you’ll find the majority of these older homes have been renovated and updated, although every now and then a “fixer upper” comes on the market!

Waverly Hills Market Update

Over the past 6 months, there has been a 15% increase in the average price per square foot in Waverly Hills Tallahassee homes for sale. Being in a seller’s market, we can anticipate this trend to continue in the near future. 

 

Approximately 12 homes sold in this neighborhood over the past 6 months, with a peak in June 2021 at 4 houses. It is typical in to see more activity in the market during summer months, and Waverly Hills was no exception. 

 

Going into the fall, the average sales price for a Waverly Hills home is $385,000, which is down from the previous 6-month average of $427,375. 

 

1961 is the average year built for homes in this neighborhood. 

 

Currently, the average number of days homes in Waverly Hills remain on the market is 43 days. Buyers can expect to pay 101% of the seller’s asking price, because of how the market is currently shaping up.

 

In August 2021, 1 home was sold in Waverly Hills. Listed at $530,000, the 4-bed, 3-bath at 2,708 sq.ft sold for $555,000. After 15 days on the market, the home sold for 104% of asking price, (or $25,000 over).

 

In September 2021, 1 home sold in the Waverly Hills neighborhood. Listed at $500,000, the 4-bed, 3-bath at 3,151 sq.ft house sold for 100% of the asking price. The Waverly Hills home sold after 2 days on the market.

 

In October 2021, 2 homes sold in the Waverly Hills area. The first home was listed at $375,000, a 4-bed, 3-baths at 2,424 sq.ft. After 151 days on the market, the home sold for $360,000, which is 96% of asking (or $15,000). The second home was a 3-bed, 2-bath at 2,088 sq.ft and listed at $400,000. Selling at 103% of asking price (or $10,000 above), at $410,000, after 23 days on the market.

Major Streets located in the Waverly Hills neighborhood

Kenilworth Road

Waverly Road

Brandemere Drive

Mercer Drive

Lothian Drive


If you love the convenient location of the Waverly Hills community, you may also wish to browse homes for sale in the nearby Midtown Tallahassee community, which is right just minutes away.


Scroll down for additional information about homes for sale in Waverly Hills Tallahassee FL. There is information about school zones, market trends, neighborhood demographics, and more.