Homes for Sale in Midtown, Tallahassee, Florida | Coldwell Banker Hartung, Inc., REALTORS

Midtown Tallahassee homes for sale

Midtown Tallahassee, located just north of downtown, consists of a cluster of smaller neighborhoods, including Durward, Forest Glen, and Gardenia Gardens. However, many locals refer to nearby subdivisions like Los Robles, Betton Hills, Waverly Hills, and Old Town as “Midtown” as well. Although there is some new construction going up in Midtown Tallahassee, most of the homes were built in the 50s. Due to the prime location, many of the older homes have been remodeled, and have held their value remarkably well. 

Midtown Tallahassee 

Midtown Tallahassee homes for saleMidtown Tallahassee is one of the city’s hippest neighborhoods. Residents enjoy all the amenities of an urban lifestyle, with a number of shops and eateries located just outside their doorsteps. Below we’ve included some information on midtown Tallahassee homes for sale, along with a few lists of some of the more popular eateries and amenities that midtown residents enjoy.

Homes for Sale 

In Midtown Tallahassee, buyers will find a mix of single-family homes on large lots, bungalow-style homes on smaller lots, duplexes, and townhouses. So no matter what your budget or style is, you’re sure to find something that meets your needs. 


Because of the variety of the homes available, prices range from the $150,000s to $500,000+. Additionally, you’ll find 2-bedroom, 1-bath homes as well as 4-bedroom, 4-bathroom houses, and everything in between. 


With the exception of new construction, the majority of homes were built in the 1950s. As such, there’s plenty of mature landscaping outside, which provides great shade in the summer months, and privacy from the neighborhoods. Many of the houses feel as if they are tucked away in their own private garden! 


Inside, buyers will find that most renovators have kept the charm of the original home while making improvements like upgraded countertops, stainless steel appliances, and refinished hardwood floors. 

Midtown Market Update 

As a reminder, the Midtown community is made up of a number of smaller neighborhoods that are clustered together in close proximity. In addition to homes for sale, there are a number of homes for rent in the area (approximately 58% of the area is comprised of renters). 
The average 6-month sales price for a Midtown home is $284,000. Looking at historical data for this area, the average sales price has ranged from $227,000 to $335,000 in recent months.
Over the past 6 months, there has been a 65% increase in the average price per square foot in Midtown Tallahassee homes for sale. Currently, it sits at approximately $185 per square foot (up from $180 last month). 
Homes in Midtown have an older charm, a number having been built in 1963, but many are bought and renovated/remodeled, which impacts the average price of a home in the area.
The average number of days on the market for houses for sale in Midtown is about 26 days; down from 45 days just two months ago. Homes are moving quickly and with the market as it is right now, buyers can expect to pay 98% of the seller’s asking price.
In January 2022, 5 homes were sold in the Midtown neighborhood; 3 detached, single-family homes, 1 townhouse, and 1 condo. The average listing price was $273,460 and the average selling price was $270,500. The majority of homes sold in January featured 3 bedrooms, and ranged from 1,080 sq.ft to 3,060 sq.ft. The average number of days these homes were on the market before selling was just 7!
In February 2022, 4 homes were sold in the Midtown neighborhood. The average listing price was $309,950 and the average selling price was $312,725. The majority of homes sold in February featured 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms and had an average of 1,656 sq.ft. They were on the market for an average of 55 days. 

 

In March 2022, 7 homes were sold in the Midtown neighborhood. The average listing price was $269,971 and the average selling price was slightly above asking, at $270,057. These homes were on the market for an average of 46 days, although some sold in as little as 2 days! 5 of the homes were single family homes and 2 were townhomes.

 

In April 2022, 6 homes sold in the neighborhood. The average list price was $354,800 and the average sold price was $354,000. As you can see, the market is still hot and in favor of sellers, with homes selling for almost full price in April. Additionally, the average time on the homes were on the market before going under contract decreased from the previous month - down from 46 days to an average of 35 days.

Midtown Tallahassee Neighborhoods 

Below are some of the neighborhoods that make up midtown Tallahassee. Click the link to view homes for sale in each neighborhood. Please note: this is a popular location for home buyers so there may not be any homes for sale in midtown at this time. Bookmark this page and check back often if this is the area of town you'd like to live in!

 

Betton Hills

Indian Head Acres

Levy Park

Los Robles

Myers Park

Old Town

Waverly Hills

Midtown Tallahassee Apartments


If you aren’t quite ready to buy, there are also a number of Midtown Tallahassee apartments available for rent, which include the Lofts at Lake Ella, Suites on 6th, Midtown Place and more. 

Major Streets located in Midtown Tallahassee FL 

6th Avenue

7th Avenue

Beard Street

Mitchell Avenue

Cherry Street

Pine Street


If you love the convenient location that Midtown Tallahassee has to offer, you may also want to explore homes for sale in the nearby Betton Hills community, which is just 5 minutes north of Midtown. 

Midtown Restaurants 

Below are just a few of the fantastic dining options easily accessible to residents and visitors of Midtown Tallahassee. To explore more local restaurants, visit choosetallahassee.com.

 

Jeri’s Cafe: a southern-style farm-to-table brunch and lunch spot.

Midtown Caboose: A laid-back, railroad-themed spot with late hours serving inventive, eclectic sandwiches & burgers. There’s also a bar with a large patio outside.  

Decent Pizza: No-frills, Seattle-grunge pizza joint with build-your-own & specialty pizzas, calzones, salads & a sizable beer list.

Table 23: the perfect dinner spot featuring southern-style meals with a large covered deck and patio. 

Kool Beanz Cafe: Popular lunch & dinner nook serving an eclectic American menu in a colorful, offbeat setting.

Midtown Tallahassee Bars 

Brass Tap

Ology Brewing

Leon Pub

Over Under Wine Bar

Midtown Shopping

When it comes to grocery stores, you’ll find a Publix shopping center at the Lake Ella Publix. Nearby There’s also a Whole Foods and an ABC Fine Wine and Spirits. 


For gifts and clothing, locals head to Alumni Hall for all things FSU, Music Masters, the Midtown Reader, lululemon, and more.


For additional information about living in Midtown Tallahassee FL, scroll down. Here, you’ll find information about school zones, market trends, neighborhood demographics, and more.