Homes for Sale in Betton Hills, Tallahassee, Florida | Coldwell Banker Hartung, Inc., REALTORS

Betton Hills Tallahassee

Betton Hills is a neighborhood located in the Midtown area of Tallahassee, Florida. It is conveniently nestled between Thomasville Road and Centerville Road, which makes it close to the action, but with the quaint nearby parks and mature trees, it feels tucked away and secluded. Scroll down to see homes for sale in Betton Hills Tallahassee, and to learn more information about this popular Tallahassee neighborhood. 

Betton Hills Tallahassee

Betton Hills Tallahassee homes for saleThere are many reasons why residents love Tallahassee’s Betton Hills neighborhood. First is the proximity to a number of popular parks. Those who live in Betton can easily walk to Winthrop Park, which has soccer fields, tennis courts, a playground and restrooms. For more seclusion, residents enjoy Chittendon Park, which has beautiful rose gardens, benches, and quiet space for relaxing and thinking. Other nearby neighborhood parks include McCord Park, Harriman Circle Park and the Betton Nature center. 

Another reason residents enjoy their neighborhood is it’s location. Many Midtown amenities are even within walking distance! Whole Foods, Zoe’s Kitchen, LuluLemon, and Fleet Feet running store are right around the corner. 

Additionally, residents can hop in their car and be in Market Square or other Tallahassee locations in just minutes. For a list of all homes currently for sale in Betton Hills, just scroll up and you’ll find them at the top of this page. 

About Betton Hills Tallahassee Homes for Sale

In the past 6 months, Technically, the Betton area is made up of multiple subdivisions that all start with “Betton”, and include the following: Betton Hills, Betton Hill, Betton Woods, Betton Estates, Betton Place and Betton Oaks. There are no major defining differences between these subdivisions, so they all tend to be referred to as “Betton Hills”. 

One fun fact is that Betton Hills is actually one of the oldest neighborhoods in all of Tallahassee! Because of this, many of the homes have spacious backyards and mature oak trees. 

In this subdivision you’ll find approximately 800 homes, with widely varying price ranges. So no matter what your budget, you can find a home within your budget in the popular Betton Hills Tallahassee neighborhood. 

Betton Hills Market Update

Over the past 6 months, there has been a 4% increase in the average price per square foot on Betton Hills homes for sale. Approximately 20 homes sold in the Betton Hills neighborhood. Right now, buyers can expect to pay 99% of the seller’s asking price. 

The average sales price for a Betton Hills home for sale is currently $371,950, which is down from the previous 6-month average of $392,000. The average year built for homes in Betton Hills is 1973. 

Currently, the average number of days homes in Betton Hills remain on the market is 26 days.

In July 2021, 3 detached single family homes sold in Betton Hills. All the homes were on just more than a .4 acre lot and were between 1,800 and 2,400 square feet. The average list price of the homes sold in July was $376,200 and the average sales price was $398,500. Like many other neighborhoods around the country and here locally, Betton Hills is in a seller's market, meaning sellers are getting top dollar for their homes.

In August 2021, 3 homes sold in Betton Hills. The average listing price was $451,633, with a high of $499,900 and a low of $400,000. The average sale price was $463,333 or 102% of asking, (which is $11,700 over). Homes sold for as high as $525,000 and as low as $400,000. Overall, homes in Betton Hills do not vary greatly in price. The homes average 3-bed, 3-bath at 2,431 sq.ft and stay on the market for 12 days.

In September 2021, 3 homes sold in the Betton Hills neighborhood. The average listing price for these homes was $453,000, with a high of $645,000 and a low of $329,000. The average selling price was $443,000, which is 98% of asking (or $10,000 below). Homes average 4-beds, 3-baths at 2,377 sq.ft and sell after 28 days on average.

In October 2021, 3 homes were sold in the Betton Hills area. The average listing price was $592,666, with a high of $800,000 and a low of $379,000; showing the wide range of house prices in this neighborhood. The average sales price was $563,333, which is 95% of asking (or $29,333 under). Homes average 4-beds, 4-baths at 2,919 sq.ft and sell after 29 days on the market. 

In November 2021, 3 homes sold in Betton Hills. The average list price was $357,500, with a high of $399,900 and a low of $335,000. For this month, on average, the actual sales price was a bit higher than the original listing price, which shows the high demand for homes in this neighborhood. The average number of days homes were on the market was 20 days, which shows inventory is moving quickly. 

In December 2021, only 1 home sold. The home was listed at $375,000 and sold for $386,000. It was located in the Betton Woods area of the subdivision. 

If you have your eyes set on a home for sale in this neighborhood, be sure to bookmark this page and check back often so you know when a new home hits the market. For more Betton Hills details, graphs and charts, scroll down this page.

Betton Hills Neighborhood Association

It is important to note that this neighborhood does not have a traditional homeowners association, like many of the other neighborhoods in Tallahassee. Back in the 1980s, the HOA covenants and restrictions lapsed, therefore there is no code enforcement. However, the Betton Hills Neighborhood Association does refer complaints to the City of Tallahassee. 

Additionally, BHNA also takes pride in keeping the neighborhood a friendly and enjoyable place to live, while protecting the area’s natural beauty. Residents are encouraged to plant trees in their yards. Additionally, many gatherings are hosted including an Easter egg hunt at Chittenden Park and Christmas caroling at Harriman Circle Park. 

For more information about the Betton Hills Neighborhood Association, click here

Local Area Schools

The Betton Hills neighborhood is zoned for the following schools: Kate Sullivan Elementary School, Cobb Middle School, and Leon High School.

There are also a number of private schools and pre-k programs in the area as well. A few are listed below for your reference:

Betton Hills Preparatory School

Seminole Montessori

Temple Israel Preschool

Streets in the Neighborhood

Some of the main streets that people live on in Betton Hills Tallahassee FL are listed below. Take a walking tour of the neighborhood here.

Armistead Road

Armstrong Road

Cline Avenue

Crestview Avenue

Harriman Circle

Lee Avenue

Marston Avenue

Mitchell Avenue

Randolph Circle

Spruce Avenue

Trescott Drive


Another neighborhood similar to Betton Hills is Waverly Hills. It’s located just down the road, so the neighborhoods are within walking distance of each other and share many amenities. For more information about this neighborhood, visit our page with information about the neighborhood here.

Betton Hills Tallahassee Real Estate

Discover what it's like to live in a Betton Hills home. View the home tour below. Ready to make the next step? Scroll down for an interactive map of all homes for sale in the area. You can also find Market Trends like the average number of days Betton Hills homes are on the market, price per square foot and more.