To see Monticello FL homes for sale, scroll through the carousel below.
For those looking to escape the hustle and bustle of Florida’s capital city, Monticello, Florida can be quite appealing. Monticello is located 26 miles from Tallahassee and 21 miles from Thomasville, GA. It is the largest town located in Jefferson County, with approximately 2,500 residents. One fun fact about Monticello is that there isn’t a single traffic light in the entire town!
If you have questions about homes for sale in Monticello, or the local housing market, read below, or contact an agent today:
At Coldwell Banker Hartung, we add new Monticello FL listings to our site every 15 minutes. We hire full-time real estate agents, to make sure buyers and sellers receive the uppermost care and attention during their real estate transaction. With our powerful search engine, you can filter by price, square footage, number of bedrooms, waterfront properties, pool homes, and more.
The median home value in Monticello, FL is $375,000. This is higher than the county median home value of $213,000. The national median home value is $308,980. The average price of homes sold in Monticello, FL is $375,000. Approximately 56% of Monticello homes are owned, compared to 29% rented, while 15% are vacant. Monticello real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale. Commercial properties are also available. If you like to see a property, contact Monticello real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
In addition to traditional single-family homes, in the area, you’ll find a number of country homes, farms and acreage, recreation properties, and investment properties as well.
In Q4 of 2021 (October - December), 45 residential homes sold in Monticello; this includes detached single-family homes, townhomes and condos. The average list price for homes in Monticello was $349,775 (compared to Tallahassee’s $283,003) and the average selling price was $342,363 (compared to Tallahassee’s $280,013). The average number of days homes sat on the market during this time period was 54.
In Monticello, during this time frame, all homes that sold were single-family homes. The least expensive was a 1,217 sq. ft. 2-bed, 2-bath home located on Hagan Street. While the most expensive home sold was a 3,346 sq. ft. 3-bed, 5-bath home on Aucilla Road, which sold for $1.2M.
In Q1 of 2022 (January - March), 36 residential homes sold. The average list price was $356,316 and the average selling price was $336,230, or approximately $20,000 under asking price. All but 2 of the homes sold were detached, single family homes (the others were townhouses). Square footage of the homes sold ranged from 775 to a whopping 8,679 sq. ft.
2 of the homes sold during Q1 2022 were more than $1M - one was on 7 acres and the other on 21 acres.
There are a number of reasons why residents love living in Monticello. The mild climate, natural beauty, and historic downtown area are appealing to those looking to escape city life. Citizens of Jefferson County take advantage of the beautiful countryside, filled with rolling hills, shady live oaks and tall pine trees.
Some of the popular activities include fishing, canoeing, hunting, bird watching, and biking. On weekends, Monticello’s historic downtown district is bustling with activities; it’s the perfect combination of country living and modern conveniences.
Click here to learn more about what it's like to live in Monticello, FL.
Explore our Instant Home Valuation tool to get an idea of what you home might be worth - no sign up or registration required!
Because of the area’s relatively low traffic, commute times are short, so many people choose to live in one city and work in another. At Coldwell Banker Hartung, we have real estate agents who live or work in Monticello as well as some of the nearby cities and towns, like Tallahassee, Crawfordville, Havana, Quincy, Thomasville, and Cairo.
Some popular neighborhoods in Monticello, Florida, are listed below:
Coopers Pond
Crooked Creek
Hiawatha Farms
The Sanctuary
Twin Acres
Just click the links above to view homes for sale in these Monticello neighborhoods. Please note, not all neighborhoods may have homes for sale at the moment, so be sure to bookmark this page and check back often if you want to buy a home in one of the subdivisions. To see all Monticello homes for sale,click here.
Use our free, easy-to-navigate search engine to look through all the neighborhoods & houses for sale in Monticello FL and the surrounding areas:
Great location convenient to Monticello just on the west end of town and an easy commute to Tallahassee. This cozy home has an open floor plan with living/dining combo, wood burning fireplace and vaulted ceilings. French doors open onto large deck for outdoor fun.
Stylish Brick Home on 5 acres with pond. Extra roomy with 3000 + sf of living area. Home has formal living and dining along with a lovey family room with fireplace off of kitchen. Additionally, there is an office and large sun-porch. Master Bedroom is extra large with oversized master bath. Easy commute to Thomasville, Georgia.
Completed home is available to see at another location...Proposed Construction on 5.2 acres Taylor Rd. Wonderful Jefferson County location. Minutes from I-10/ Gamble Rd. + downtown Monticello. New 5 lot mini subdivision paved frontage, minimal restrictions to protect values. Underground County water available.
Priced at appraised value. Square footage includes both the main house is 3200 square feet with 4 bedrooms and 3 baths. Brand new barn apartment is 1400 square feet with 2 bedrooms and 1 bath. This would be an amazing income producing property for short and/or long term rental property of barn apt, horse boarding stables ... or even a wedding venue. This breathtaking property checks ALL of the boxes! Please see associated docs as this home has so many features and details. Driving through the gated entry, you are greeted with Argentine Bahia Grass green pastures and most charming property. Five fenced and cross fenced pastures each with run in shelters, electric and water. Multiple level main main house is perfect for multi-generational living showcasing exposed beams, vaulted ceilings, bricked walls, and decked with tongue and groove hardwood ceilings. In-law/Guest Studio Suite also has private entrance with patio, mini kitchen, separate living space and walk-in shower. New 5000 square foot barn with 4 stalls, tack room, RV/Trailer parking. Barn also includes newly completed 2 bedroom / 1 bath apartment featuring spectacular 40 foot wood beam stretching across the entire living/ dining / kitchen space. Barn apartment has 40 foot deck overlooking pastures. As you walk through the property... enjoy many landscaped nooks, gravel walk ways, a large chicken coop, kids play area, above ground pool area (could be used for dog pen), rustic smaller barn used as a workshop, parking pavilion, and endless views of well manicured pastures.
Last house on the right! Tucked away with privacy. 2 bed 2 Bath 2020 year model mobile home. In light lived in condition. On 2 well spaced acres with a couple out buildings and carport. Well landscaped and partial woods. High speed internet available with well and septic included. Close to Monticello FL and Thomasville GA. By appointment only.
Gorgeous new construction featuring spacious open floor plan. Kitchen has raised cabinets, granite counters, stainless steel appliances, large island with plenty of seating & a pantry....overlooks spacious family area with plenty of room for large gatherings, plus separate dining space. First floor also offers 1/2 bath and large storage area under stairs. Upstairs you are greeted with open reading area or study and laundry room. Large master bedroom with on-suite...double sinks and more granite. Walk-in closet and just off nook is optional "his" closet. Two spacious bedrooms and another large bathroom. This home also has a front porch and 2 car garage; is within walking distance to library, historic downtown and coffee house. Pictures are of a model home nearby.
This charming 2 Bed, 2 Bath Fully Renovated Home in historic Monticello, Florida is a must-see home! This beautifully renovated 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom home seamlessly blends contemporary upgrades with classic charm. Every inch of this residence has been meticulously remodeled to offer comfort and style. This is not a flip. The owners expected to live in this home and every detail was made with their long-term living comfort in mind. Step inside to find a cozy living space filled with natural light, perfect for enjoying our beautiful sunny weather. The kitchen boasts brand-new stainless steel appliances, butcher block countertops, and custom cabinetry. Both bathrooms feature elegant fixtures and finishes, providing a spa-like experience. Enjoy the spacious master suite with a HUGE walk-in closet and a private, fully updated bathroom. The second bedroom is generously sized, ideal for guests or a home office. Outside, the property includes a large, backyard perfect for relaxation or gatherings around the firepit, and the back deck offers a perfect place to shelter and watch our summer afternoon rains. This move-in-ready home is an exceptional find in a quiet, friendly neighborhood close to Monticello's walkable downtown. Don t miss your chance to own a piece of modern elegance in a picturesque town. Check out this unique home today!
Nature Lover s Dream! Custom-Built Estate on 21+ Acres with Endless Amenities. Discover the perfect blend of luxury and tranquility with this one-of-a-kind home, designed for those who crave space and natural beauty. Main Level Highlights: Eat-in kitchen with gas stove & butler s pantry. for extra storage. Separate dining room plus living and family rooms for versatile spaces. Charming library/music room with warm wood accents. Master suite with private access to a screened-in porch overlooking a sparkling heated saltwater pool & spa. Two additional bedrooms on the first floor. Upper-Level Highlights: Two more spacious bedrooms & two full baths. Large playroom or office space. Plus a massive 23x44 bonus room with wet bar perfect for entertaining! Separate Living Space Above Carport. A full bathroom and private room, ideal for an in-law suite or college student. Outdoor Amenities for Every Lifestyle: Saltwater Pool with Spa, Cook house for outdoor feasts, Pole barn, chicken coop, and smaller barn for farming. With breathtaking views, abundant space, and so many thoughtful features, this property offers the perfect escape from the ordinary.
PRICED $20,000 BELOW RECENT APPRAISAL!! Welcome to your forever home on the most stunningly manicured 5.5+ acres nestled in a serene country setting. This is truly a showstopper starting right at the beginning with its grand gated entrance leading to a picturesque rocking chair front porch and a modern farmhouse aesthetic. Walking in the front door you ll be greeted by a cathedral vault ceiling, a stone wood-burning fireplace and a stunning catwalk staircase that creates the focal point for the heart of the home with its beautiful architectural details. With an open and inviting feel leading you to the kitchen, you won t miss the gorgeous white cabinets, stainless steel appliances and large island perfect for entertaining and large gatherings. This primary suite is sure to catch your attention offering a separate sitting area with French doors leading out the front porch or to cozy up with a book next to the double-sided fireplace. The bedroom is expansive with huge bay windows allowing tons of natural light to flow through. The primary bathroom is brilliant and luxurious with its floor to ceiling marble and massive curbless shower featuring two showering stations and a built-in bench. This walk-in closet will suit anyone s needs with its expansive island, built in drawers and floor to ceiling shoe rack! Upstairs features two large guest bedrooms with charming dormers overlooking the front. Off one guest room you will find an epic theater room equipped with glow in the dark carpet and the perfect setup for any avid movie watchers - you can fit a projector, stadium seating & a popcorn machine! Off the other guest room is an additional bonus room for a perfect teen hangout, office space, gym setup, you name it! As if the house wasn t enough, there is also a 2,400 sqft workshop with four roll-up garage doors, electricity and tons of storage for large equipment. There s also a concrete RV parking pad with 50 amp hookups! The main home is equipped with a whole house generator as well as a 2022 roof to provide peace of mind for the long term. This property truly has it all in the most private and tranquil setting. Come see for yourself and don t miss this opportunity! *Audio/video surveillance inside home*
New build, under construction! Beautiful, private lot on 2.62 acres, close to downtown Monticello and no HOA!! 5 mins to I-10 and 4 mins to US90 - - > see similar new build, under construction @ 149 Coopers Pond on 1.05 acres coming soon!
Monticello 5 bedroom/2 ba /2659sq ft home. There is a separate mother n law/guest home that has 3 bedrooms/2 baths & 1861 sq.ft. that is also available to purchase (mls#366064). This one story brick home has a Brand new roof in Oct/'23, approx. 1.3 acres for the left parcel and 1.9 for both as well as an RV pad (no HOA). Other features include a whole house generator, nice sized laundry room, new interior paint, new refrigerator and oven and a large fireplace. This property is conveniently located off of HWY 90 East close to I10, shopping and restaurants. Perfect for multigenerational families or those wanting rental income/air b&b.
**SEPT 2024 APPRAISAL CAME BACK AT $ 3 1 9 , 0 0 0 !** Motivated Sellers have reduced the list price to $309,000; instant equity! **Back on the market due to an unforeseen variable with the Seller's existing mortgage company. NOTE - The issue is in the process of being fully resolved, and will not effect the ability of any future deal to transfer** This home is located inside the Monticello city limits on Hwy 90 East, but tucked away with a white gate out front, and an above ground pool in the backyard; perfect for beating the year-round heat and complete with privacy fence in the back. This home has just under 2000 sq ft of living space, and has a great layout with a versatile 4th room, which is currently being used as a 4th bedroom, but was previously used as an office/study by the prior homeowner; it could also very easily be utilized as a library, den, music room, or like. SEE ALSO MLS #366252 - for secondary listing as a 4 BR/2 BA with OFFICE/STUDY. Hard wood floors throughout the main living areas, luxury vinyl plank in the bedrooms and master bath, and tile in the kitchen, laundry room and guest bath. The master bedroom has a tray ceiling and the master bathroom has been completely renovated to include a beautiful custom tiled shower with double shower-heads, a double vanity, a large linen closet with built-in shelving, and luxury vinyl plank floors. An inside utility room, separate, attached outdoor storage shed with an added loft space, currently being used as a playroom, and a separate concrete pad, ideal for outdoor cookouts. BONUS - the adjacent lot (north) is also for sale! Perfect opportunity to increase your backyard space for the kids/pets to play OR for some added parking if a detached garage or carport is what your after. Please note - this a a modular home, for full disclosure.
Great single family home situated on large lot in desirable Coopers Pond Community near I-10 East. Own this 3 bedrooms 2 bathrooms home as a first time home buyer or retirement home. It is currently occupied with a tenant and can be purchased with an opportunity of immediate income. New roof 2024, ceramic tile floors throughout, partially fenced back yard, large patio with one car garage. A separate duplex is For Sale at 1496 and 1498 Hampton Place next to the property. See MLS with full details. Perfect for families or friend to stay near each other.
**This property is currently tenant occupied and requires advance notice for showings, but easy to show **Current lease is in effect through April 2025; lease details available upon request** Beautiful 1456 sq ft, 2000 year mobile home on 0.64 acres (2 parcels - Id 00-00-00-0360-0000-1611 + 00-00-00-0360-0000-1650). This home has been completely renovated with upgrades including a new metal roof, updated bathrooms, an updated kitchen with high end stainless steel appliances and luxury vinyl plank floors throughout. A great buy at $149,900!
Stately brick home in gated community of Hiawatha Farms~high elevation with 8.2 fenced pastoral acres perfect for horses~great split bedroom floorplan plus office~rocking chair front porch~large screen room overlooking backyard~3-car garage~HUGE walk in closet in master~wood-burning fireplace~separate cottage perfect for guests or teenagers~cottage also has large screened room~garage plus a covered bay for farm equipment or could be converted into horse stalls~this property consists of 3 lots totaling the 8.2 acres~homeowners association dues are $315 per lot
Amazing new construction 3 bedroom 2 bathroom by Nailed It Tallahassee LLC. Luxurious master suite, Kitchen made of dreams, this is a must see!
Private Country Estate on 14.74 acres. Two living areas ideal for multi-generational living or in-law suite. Upper level offers great room with fireplace and large spacious kitchen, formal living and dining and theater room. Four bedrooms 3 1/2 baths which includes two master suites! Lower lever has full roomy kitchen, great room, master bedroom , additional bedrooms, two full baths, library, sunroom, hobby room. Barn includes apartment/workshop/walk in cooler. Two car carport. Grounds include pond/creek/ grape orchard! Large deck and patio for entertaining. Planted pines, open fields. Great horse potential just 15 minutes to Tallahassee off of East Hwy 90.
Discover your dream home perfect for multi generational families in the beautiful and serene, horse-friendly neighborhood of Hiawatha Farms. This private, gated community offers peace, tranquility and privacy while being conveniently located just 1 mile from I-10 and a quick 10 minute drive to Tallahassee. This spacious home offers the perfect blend of comfort and convenience, featuring a main house with open living spaces, modern kitchen with granite countertops and eat in dining, formal dining room, office space, very large master suite and cozy bedrooms, bonus/sun room, alongside a fully-equipped mother-in-law/guest cottage suite, with full kitchen, ideal for guests or extended family. Between the two homes sits a large and spacious covered pergola, perfect for outdoor entertaining. Located in a prime spot, you'll enjoy the tranquility of country living with easy access to city amenities. Fenced and ready for horses! Don't miss this rare opportunity!
Come check out this cozy ranch style home in downtown Monticello! Walking distance to downtown for shopping and dining. Roomy kitchen with bar. Extra room could be den or dining. Built in bookshelves in living room . Very private backyard area in quite neighborhood.
No money down with USDA loan! Discover your dream home in charming Monticello! This nearly new, one-story gem boasts an open concept design with a split floor plan, perfect for modern living. The spacious primary bedroom offers a private retreat, while the screened-in porch invites outdoor relaxation. Impress guests with stunning 10-foot tray ceilings, granite countertops, and custom cabinetry. Enjoy the fenced yard for added privacy and peace of mind, and transfer switch installed for easy generator hook up. Minutes from historic downtown, your perfect blend of comfort and convenience awaits!
Rare 4 bedroom 2 bath home located 4 blocks away from downtown Monticello and walking distance to most of the popular restaurants and shops. Home features a spacious floor plan with hardwood floors throughout. Eminities include dining room, laundry room. a tankless hot water heater to conserve space. Also a spacious front porch. Backyard has an additional dwelling unit that could be in-law suite, work shop, or storage area. Home also has a large patio deck with built in brick barbecue grill with and additional wood burning brick fire pit away from the deck. This home won't take much to make it your dream home.
Stunning turnkey home on 5.5 acres on the highly sought after Gamble Road in Jefferson County, FL. Built in 2020, the bright and spacious 5 bedroom, 4.5 bathroom home is full of custom features! Downstairs features an open concept living space with beautiful kitchen, quartz countertops and island with seating. Kitchen and dining space flow into the living room, with French doors to the patio. Two downstairs bedrooms both have ensuite bathrooms. The downstairs primary suite offers a soaking tub, walk-in shower and spacious double vanity. Huge downstairs utility room even has it's own half bathroom! Upstairs you are met with three additional bedrooms. Two bedrooms have access to a jack and jill bathroom, with an additional guest bathroom off the landing and bonus space. The bonus nook would be perfect for storage, a small office, or adorable reading nook. The huge parking pad, with basketball hoop, is easily accessible from a side door with direct access to the kitchen. The 5.5 acres is mostly grassy open space with tons of room for outbuildings or recreation, plus a 50amp camper hookup! The gated driveway with woods along the property edges makes for the perfect amount of privacy. You'll have an easy 15 minute ride to Tallahassee as well 15 minutes to Monticello for any in town needs. Fresh paint, great appliances, beautiful floors... This home is a true must see! *All room dimensions and lot lines in photos are approximate, buyer is responsible for verifying exact dimensions.
Amazing new construction 3 bedroom 2 bathroom by Nailed It Tallahassee LLC. Luxurious master suite, Kitchen made of dreams, this is a must see!
Very nice home located on wooded acreage, all high and dry with great access to Tallahassee. Several outbuildings will remain on the property. They are good for storage, workshop, etc. Home and buildings are in very good condition. Showing is by appointment only, minimum of 24 hours needed to set up showing.
New Roof! New HVAC! Some repairs needed such as finishing half bath. Nearly a half acre of stunning backyard on the lake with outbuilding and shed for picnics and gatherings. Enclosed carport increases living/gathering space inside! So much opportunity here!