To see Monticello FL homes for sale, scroll through the carousel below.
For those looking to escape the hustle and bustle of Florida’s capital city, Monticello, Florida can be quite appealing. Monticello is located 26 miles from Tallahassee and 21 miles from Thomasville, GA. It is the largest town located in Jefferson County, with approximately 2,500 residents. One fun fact about Monticello is that there isn’t a single traffic light in the entire town!
If you have questions about homes for sale in Monticello, or the local housing market, read below, or contact an agent today:
At Coldwell Banker Hartung, we add new Monticello FL listings to our site every 15 minutes. We hire full-time real estate agents, to make sure buyers and sellers receive the uppermost care and attention during their real estate transaction. With our powerful search engine, you can filter by price, square footage, number of bedrooms, waterfront properties, pool homes, and more.
The median home value in Monticello, FL is $295,000. This is lower than the county median home value of $365,000. The national median home value is $277,796. The average price of homes sold in Monticello, FL is $295,000. Approximately 57% of Monticello homes are owned, compared to 29% rented, while 14% are vacant. Monticello real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale. Commercial properties are also available. If you like to see a property, contact Monticello real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
In addition to traditional single-family homes, in the area, you’ll find a number of country homes, farms and acreage, recreation properties, and investment properties as well.
In Q4 of 2021 (October - December), 45 residential homes sold in Monticello; this includes detached single-family homes, townhomes and condos. The average list price for homes in Monticello was $349,775 (compared to Tallahassee’s $283,003) and the average selling price was $342,363 (compared to Tallahassee’s $280,013). The average number of days homes sat on the market during this time period was 54.
In Monticello, during this time frame, all homes that sold were single-family homes. The least expensive was a 1,217 sq. ft. 2-bed, 2-bath home located on Hagan Street. While the most expensive home sold was a 3,346 sq. ft. 3-bed, 5-bath home on Aucilla Road, which sold for $1.2M.
In Q1 of 2022 (January - March), 36 residential homes sold. The average list price was $356,316 and the average selling price was $336,230, or approximately $20,000 under asking price. All but 2 of the homes sold were detached, single family homes (the others were townhouses). Square footage of the homes sold ranged from 775 to a whopping 8,679 sq. ft.
2 of the homes sold during Q1 2022 were more than $1M - one was on 7 acres and the other on 21 acres.
There are a number of reasons why residents love living in Monticello. The mild climate, natural beauty, and historic downtown area are appealing to those looking to escape city life. Citizens of Jefferson County take advantage of the beautiful countryside, filled with rolling hills, shady live oaks and tall pine trees.
Some of the popular activities include fishing, canoeing, hunting, bird watching, and biking. On weekends, Monticello’s historic downtown district is bustling with activities; it’s the perfect combination of country living and modern conveniences.
Click here to learn more about what it's like to live in Monticello, FL.
Explore our Instant Home Valuation tool to get an idea of what you home might be worth - no sign up or registration required!
.png)
Because of the area’s relatively low traffic, commute times are short, so many people choose to live in one city and work in another. At Coldwell Banker Hartung, we have real estate agents who live or work in Monticello as well as some of the nearby cities and towns, like Tallahassee, Crawfordville, Havana, Quincy, Thomasville, and Cairo.
Some popular neighborhoods in Monticello, Florida, are listed below:
Coopers Pond
Crooked Creek
Hiawatha Farms
The Sanctuary
Twin Acres
Just click the links above to view homes for sale in these Monticello neighborhoods. Please note, not all neighborhoods may have homes for sale at the moment, so be sure to bookmark this page and check back often if you want to buy a home in one of the subdivisions. To see all Monticello homes for sale,click here.
Use our free, easy-to-navigate search engine to look through all the neighborhoods & houses for sale in Monticello FL and the surrounding areas:
New Construction to begin soon - 4 Bedroom 2 bath home will feature custom detailing throughout. Custom cabinetry, tile design and wood work, granite counter tops, stainless steel appliances, pot filler, walk in pantry, screen in back porch. Estimated time of completion March/April 2023 ***Pictures are from previously built model***
New Construction to begin soon - 4 Bedroom 2 bath home will feature custom detailing throughout. Custom cabinetry, tile design and wood work, granite counter tops, stainless steel appliances, pot filler, walk in pantry, screen in back porch. Estimated time of completion March/April 2023 ***Pictures are from previously built model***
Cottage just down the street from the Wacissa River Put-In. Nice 2 Bedroom Cottage with Hard Wood Floors and Metal Roof. Seller is replacing the Hot water Heater, prior to closing. Nice Rocking Chair front Porch and screened Back Porch. Property also has storage Shed.
If you're looking for a farm, look no further. This property has a lot to offer, including multiple barns, horse stalls, outbuildings, a pond, various water sources/electrical outlets all over the property. Monticello is a short commute to Tallahassee and Thomasville, thus enabling you to live in a quiet, peaceful, rural town and enjoy all that nature has to offer, while having convenient travel roads and a short commute to shopping, dining, schools and medical facilities. Some of the Seller's FAVORITE things about this home/property - SUNSETS! Truly some of the best sunset views Mother Nature has to offer. Sellers also love the privacy (home cannot be seen from the road), gorgeous oak trees and the quaint, historical charm that Monticello offers. The home and/or horse stables could easily be renovated/converted in a way to offer multiple living quarters with private access, thus making it great for multi-generational living or income producing. The house offers 5 BR's/3 BA's, with the owner's suite being very private from the main living area of the house and a closet space many dream of having. 4 of the BR's are downstairs - Upstairs has a semi-private sitting/living area, along with a storage closet, BR and BA. Selling as-is with the right to inspect. All measurements are approximate - Buyer responsible for verifying, if important.
This Monticello property is 23 miles from Tallahassee on the west side of Monticello, FL. The house sits on 7 acres on an attractive, fertile, rolling setting with fruit trees and pasture. The land fronts one of Florida’s most beautiful roadways, U.S. 90 between Tallahassee and charming Monticello. The 2088 sq. ft. home, constructed in 2002, received a 2014 makeover with a new roof, windows, and doors. The fresh white paint on all interior trim and walls is the ideal “blank canvas†for creative interior decorating. The cathedral living room ceiling soars. A staircase leads to a loft for a fourth sleeping area, office, or playroom. Still, the expansive backyard has a mixture of grass and woodlands that could be fenced for a nice 3-4 acre horse paddock. The land itself is exceptional. The fertile sandy loam soils are perfect for the backyard vineyard and fruit tree orchard with citrus, peach, plums, nectarine, and pears. They are also superior gardening soils.
Welcome to horse lovers’ paradise! This Jefferson County gem offers an ideal, and much sought-after combination of home, acreage, infrastructure and location. The home features 38+ acres, a 2600 sq ft custom home, and 6 stall barn with tack and wash bays. Ideally located between Tallahassee and historic Monticello, offering a short 10-minute commute to I-10; you’ll enjoy both privacy and convenience. Sit on a true southern front porch and enjoy pasture views of your animals. Or keep an eye out for the abundant wildlife that share this special place. Upon entering this unique home, the foyer is flanked by a formal dining room before entering a casually elegant family room centered around a brick, wood burning fireplace with custom wood and tile details. And to top it off, a wet bar for your favorite beverage while deciding which game to take in. This 2 bed / 2 bath home features 10’ ceilings with crown moldings throughout. The eat in kitchen boasts stone counters, two sinks, a gas range, appliance garages and a large pantry. The Master Bed and Bath are spacious and beautifully detailed. And yes, there is a second fireplace for those cozy winter evenings. Meander down to the pool and hot tub, add water and you are ready for hot summer days after a long ride. Each living space offers spectacular views of your private paradise. Schedule an appointment now to see this special property.
Custom home with over 25 private acres! This prime private property is completed by a guesthouse and a fully air-conditioned workshop, each with its own full bathroom. You are close to the nice Monticello Restaurants and shops. Under a 30-minute travel to NE and East Tallahassee, Florida. New Roof in September 2022. New HVAC, in July 2022. Bonus designer-built gazebo for your enjoyment. The recently updated chef's kitchen has granite tops and space to spare. This home has many upgraded features. Enjoy the open concept floor plan PLUS a formal dining room, formal living room, dedicated office, and extra-large bedrooms, all with 10 ft. ceilings. The real hardwood floors are in top condition. 5 Baths. You will like the oversized 3-car garage and another oversized 3-car garage comes with the workshop. There is generous driveway parking with both buildings. Whole house Generator. The downstairs air-conditioned workshop/studio has high ceilings, a dedicated bathroom, and expansive built-in storage. The top floor is an open living space with an open kitchen, huge great room, and a full bathroom. The 25 acres has 5 individual parcels, each 5 acres MOL individually surveyed and approved by the county but not yet taxed separately! Owners could sell up to 4- 5 acre parcels to make money or build 4 more houses. Nature abounds here. You can see a new movie every day here watching the animals, deer, turkey, birds galore, raccoons, rabbits, and more! There are also 2 private shooting ranges on-site, up to 300 meters, with safety berms. (The current owners do not hunt on this property). The place is nicely landscaped and has generous paved parking in front of the main house and additional paved parking in front of the detached guest house/workshop. You could also make this a gated community, there are a total of 7, 5-acre parcels. This seller is relocating out of state. There are low electrical rates here with Tri-county-electric-cooperative. Schedule a tour today!
Open House, September 25, 2022, 2:00 PM - 4:00 PM. Beautiful 1974 home with complete built out basement for a mother-in-law suite! Mother-In-Law suite has access to enter and exit without going through main house. 2 Car Garage, Swimming Pool, Gazebo, over an acre of property. Family room, Living Room, Dining Room, Large Laundry Room. Convenient to the historic downtown Monticello.
10 homesites available to choose from! Beautiful New Construction in Crooked Creek!! 3 Bedrooms with 2 full baths and large Office, huge Primary suite furnished with gorgeous tiled shower stall and garden tub. Quartz countertops throughout and LVP flooring. Gorgeous fireplace in spacious living area with trey ceilings. Stainless steel appliances with large island for entertaining. Rear porch to enjoy the backyard privacy. Photograph is of previous build.
Beautiful New Construction in Crooked Creek!! 3 Bedrooms with 2 full baths and large Office, huge Primary suite furnished with gorgeous tiled shower stall and garden tub. Quartz countertops throughout and LVP flooring. Gorgeous fireplace in spacious living area with trey ceilings. Stainless steel appliances with large island for entertaining. Rear porch to enjoy the backyard privacy.
Luxury home with over 7500 sq. ft. under roof, on 5 acres, maximized with comfortable living spaces and layouts that can host varieties of entertaining scenarios both indoors and outdoors. Superior brick, 4 Bedroom, 4 Bath, fully equipped kitchen, 2 offices, downstairs primary ensuite, wall of windows overlooking rear entertaining oasis, stacked stone outdoor fireplace, generator, ice maker, rear porch flagstone patio/pergola & wet bar, front covered brick porch, oak flooring, granite counter tops, plus other premium upgrades. Incredibly maintained! Impeccable condition! The 40x30 barn has separate, air conditioned 12x40 kennel/storage area. Concrete driveway, matching brick columnar gated entry with wrought iron fencing within a mile of charming Monticello, FL. Tallahassee, FL is 26 miles. Closest Publix is 21.7 miles in Thomasville, GA.
Photos Coming Soon! Solid Custom Brick Home in the Heart of Monticello on beautiful oak lined street! Over 2000 sf with updated appliances and quartz kitchen counters. Eat in Kitchen, separate dinning, cozy living room with wood burning fireplace. Master suite has adjoining 19x13 room for third bedroom or sitting area/office. Extra large utility room 10x9 with hanging rack and lots of storage. Fenced back yard with deck off of sun porch and storage building. Walking distance to beautiful downtown Monticello !
*There is no real estate sign on the property, per HOA guidelines* This is a 55 or better community. 2005 Riley Palmer construction. 1 of only 8 townhouses in this exclusive neighborhood located in the hear of downtown Monticello. Full listing details will be available shortly!
Beautiful 1945 home with guest cottage! Home has great flow, good storage and vintage charm. The main Home is 1988 square feet with 3 bedrooms and 1.5 bath. Cottage is 1 bedroom 1 bath, 598 square feet. The main home features a cozy living room with original wood floors as you enter the home, French doors lead to a Sunroom or office off of the living room. The Master bedroom has an attached half bath, (it was originally a full bath and could easily be made back into a full bath). Original wood floors in most of the home. Sunroom windows are original, all others were updated recently to match the original craftsman style. At the rear of the home is a spacious Family room that provides plenty of natural light and great views with wall to wall windows and bricked wall fireplace. This house is move in ready but still has some small projects that could be done if buyer wanted to give it their own touch. The guest cottage was last rented in late 2019 for $800 per month, and should bring more now. You will not lack for storage, the bedrooms in the main home all have walk in closets, there are two sheds on the property. There is covered parking for 4 vehicles with the open garage and attached carport. Over 1 acre with beautiful mature Pecan Trees, Magnolias and native Palms. For the fruit lover there are Peach and Pear Trees as well as Kiwi. This property has something for everyone and backs up to 100 acre plantation. Schedule to see it today!
"A CREEK RUNS THROUGH IT" 10 acres with a 2017 double wide. The most gorgeous woodlands you can POSSIBLY envision with a clear, sandy bottom creek that winds through the entire bottom section. Set back off the road on a little crest that overlooks the woodlands, this 3 Bdrm, 2 Bth, has a 4th room you can make an office, toy room or craft space. Community Water, septic tank, underground power, and entire front yard is already fenced. Must have prequalification letter in hand for "2nd set up" or proof of funds. Located between Monticello, FL and Tallahassee, FL. Additional 16 acres adjacent to subject property, is under contract, please ask about the roadway easement that comes through the property to get to the 16 acres.
Beautiful Country Living - Sit on the big rocking chair front porch and watch the donkeys at play in the field across the highway. This is true country living with the benefits of being close to everything in charming downtown Monticello. This immaculate split Master Bedroom home is perfect for a starter or forever home. There is plenty of outside storage in the huge pole barn (aprox 20x50), pump shed, separate utility and a she/he shed (14x16) with air conditioning. You can also relax in the Florida room while watching the children or pets play in the completely fenced yard with electric gate. There is plenty of room on this 1 acre property for a garden too. Come see this charming property and begin making your quiet country living dream come true today.
Gorgeous new construction - features spacious open floor plan. Kitchen has raised cabinets, granite counters, stainless steel appliances, large island with plenty of seating, pantry and overlooks spacious family area with plenty of room for large gatherings, plus separate dining space. First floor also offers 1/2 bath and large storage area under stairs. Upstairs you are greeted with open reading area or study and laundry room. Large master bedroom with on suite with double sinks and more granite. Walk in closet and just off nook optional "his" closet. Two spacious bedrooms and another large bathroom. This home offers a front porch overlooking Monticello Ecological Park with walking trails. Walking distance to library, historic downtown and coffee house. 2 car garage with alley access.
Gorgeous new construction - features spacious open floor plan. Kitchen has raised cabinets, granite counters, stainless steel appliances, large island with plenty of seating, pantry and overlooks spacious family area with plenty of room for large gatherings, plus separate dining space. First floor also offers 1/2 bath and large storage area under stairs. Upstairs you are greeted with open reading area or study and laundry room. Large master bedroom with on suite with double sinks and more granite. Walk in closet and just off nook optional "his" closet. Two spacious bedrooms and another large bathroom. This home offers a front porch overlooking Monticello Ecological Park with walking trails. Walking distance to library, historic downtown and coffee house. 2 car garage with alley access.
This multi-family property parcel consists of 4 buildings each featuring 2 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and an open floor plan for the kitchen/living area. The units were completely updated/rebuilt in 2018 to include all new: roofs, ac units, electrical, plumbing, insulation/drywall, vinyl plank flooring, appliances, cabinetry & light fixtures throughout. Located less than 20 miles from the newly constructed Amazon warehouse, this property is an investors’ dream! This multi-family property parcel consists of 4 buildings each featuring 2 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and an open floor plan for the kitchen/living area. The units were completely updated/rebuilt in 2018 to include all new: roofs, ac units, electrical, plumbing, insulation/drywall, vinyl plank flooring, appliances, cabinetry & light fixtures throughout. Located less than 20 miles from the newly constructed Amazon warehouse, this property is an investors’ dream! Rents: Unit 1538 is $850 per month, Unit 1540 is $800 per month, Unit 1542 is $950 per month and Unit 1544 is $850 per month. Yearly rents are $41,400. Yearly Expenses: Taxes: $3,037.49, Insurance: $4,112, Water: $432, Lawn care: $1,020 and Maintenance: $1,200. Yearly Expenses are $9,801.49 Yearly NOI: $31,598.51
!!Price Improvement!! Location! Location! Location! Country living with plenty of privacy but just a short drive to the conveniency of city living. This beautiful 3 bedroom 2 bath home sits on approximately 8.8 acres with an approximate 3 minute walk to the Wacissa River Landing. Talk about Prime Location! 12837 Gamble Road is only 20 minutes from Tallahassee, you can drive to the coast in approximately 15 minutes and has plenty of potential for investment property income. The interior of this home has solid pine walls, 2019 metal roof, and windows with a lifetime warranty and has been well maintained. This home also has 3 outbuildings that consist of a barn, shop, and storage facilities. Bring your livestock and come home to the country!
Like New! Barely lived in 2021 Home in sought after Crooked Creek Subdivision! New in August of 2021. Easy commute to Thomasville and Tallahassee with the small town charm of Monticello! This beautiful 3/2 is on a spacious corner lot. Features and Upgrades include Stainless appliances, recessed lighting and granite counter tops. Generous counter space. Three spacious bedrooms with generous closets and a nice walk in closet in the Master! Beautiful screened lanai with indoor/outdoor carpet. A great place to enjoy your morning coffee and enjoy the peaceful surroundings. Many Upgrades Include, Recessed Lighting, Granite Counter tops, Gutters with Leaf Guards and many more! This home is a must see in Monticello! Still covered by builders Warranties
Expansive 5556 Square Foot home was built over original farm home. Large 7000 SqFt well-insulated metal shop/barn with garage-type doors and silo. Flat 10.3 acres located in gated Hiawatha Farms equestrian community minutes from town. New paint inside/out. New flooring. Includes an in law suite with private entrance, kitchenette, living area, ADA ramp and shower - can also be owners suite. Huge 3 car garage. Owner used two offices as extra bedrooms. This one-of-a-kind home can be configured many ways.
Location! Location! Location! Enjoy all things Monticello has to offer. This three bedroom one bath home has tons of potential. Walk or bike to school or downtown. Easy access to Hwy 90 or Hwy 19. Perfect location for retiree or first time buyer.
RESTORED CENTURY-OLD MONTICELLO HOME. This attractive two-story 2733 sq. ft home with 5 bedrooms and 3 baths is located in charming Monticello, about 30 minutes east of Tallahassee. The historic old home, thought to have been built in 1921, sits in a good neighborhood on a 0.55 acre lot that has been freshly landscaped and includes 3 out buildings—an original 2-car garage that has been converted to an air-conditioned workshop/project room, the original old smokehouse, and a more recently added storage shed. The house has new siding and all new windows. The interior has fresh finishes throughout including new paint and just-refinished wood floors. A former owner did an extensive upgrade and remodeling of the kitchen several years ago. The 3 bathrooms are modest but very functional with many new fixtures and fresh paint. The two fireplaces have gas logs. There’s a wet bar with a wine cooler. Hot water is from an on-demand gas water heater. One of the two AC units is new. There’s even an old attic fan that works great for pulling in fresh air on a pleasant day. The carport has an RV/EV plug-in. An in-ground backyard pool, has been decked over. It needs a new liner but is probably restorable. Monticello is one of North Florida’s most pleasant communities with a friendly rural culture. Downtown Monticello is also undergoing a renaissance with lots of remodeling of old buildings and quaint new shops. Jefferson is the only county in Florida with no traffic lights, yet it is very convenient to urban area services in Tallahassee and Thomasville, GA. Move-in ready! Termite bond. Recent survey certifiable to a new owner.
Do you want to live in the country on 5 acres, surrounded by a cattle farm with internet access? Then this is the place for you! This beautiful ranch style, 5 bedroom & 3 full bathroom home, sits on a spacious 5 acre lot in eastern Jefferson County. Located just 10 minutes east of Monticello, 5 minutes to I-10, and 3 minutes to the local private school, Aucilla Christian Academy. Walking through the front door, you are greeted with a large 14x35 living room with wood burning fireplace. Through the foyer you come into another large room, 39x14, with a matching wood burning fireplace, dining room and kitchen. All wood cabinets in the kitchen and stainless steel appliances. With a few upgrades this kitchen could be a showstopper! On the north end of the house there are 4 bedrooms including a master bedroom, bathroom, and walk-in closet, along with 3 guest bedrooms and a guest bathroom. The bathrooms on this end of the home have their own septic tank and water heater. On the south side of the house there is a 5th bedroom and 3rd bathroom, perfect for a mother-in-law suite or office. There is another septic tank and water heater on the south end of the house for the kitchen, laundry, and 3rd bathroom. Large interior laundry room with access to the two-car garage and the screened in back porch! The screened in back porch is where you will want to be every evening rocking in your rocking chair, watching the incredible sunsets overlooking the neighboring cattle farm. The yard is adorned with many types of fruit-bearing trees and bushes including; Peaches, Plums, Blueberries, Mulberries, and Oranges. The owner has been selling his blueberries for about 17 years and he makes about $2,500/year off the crop. HVAC is less than 8 years old and there is a 50-year metal roof on the home. The property has a small storage shed with turkey coop, 2 pole barns, a large workshop with 220 power and water in place! The barns need some love, but could be great for a workshop, stables or storage for large equipment. The property is fully fenced with 2 pastures and a run in shed, ready to go for your livestock. This place won’t last long, so schedule your showings today!!
