To see Monticello FL homes for sale, scroll through the carousel below.
For those looking to escape the hustle and bustle of Florida’s capital city, Monticello, Florida can be quite appealing. Monticello is located 26 miles from Tallahassee and 21 miles from Thomasville, GA. It is the largest town located in Jefferson County, with approximately 2,500 residents. One fun fact about Monticello is that there isn’t a single traffic light in the entire town!
If you have questions about homes for sale in Monticello, or the local housing market, read below, or contact an agent today:
At Coldwell Banker Hartung, we add new Monticello FL listings to our site every 15 minutes. We hire full-time real estate agents, to make sure buyers and sellers receive the uppermost care and attention during their real estate transaction. With our powerful search engine, you can filter by price, square footage, number of bedrooms, waterfront properties, pool homes, and more.
The median home value in Monticello, FL is $344,450. This is higher than the county median home value of $213,000. The national median home value is $308,980. The average price of homes sold in Monticello, FL is $344,450. Approximately 56% of Monticello homes are owned, compared to 29% rented, while 15% are vacant. Monticello real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale. Commercial properties are also available. If you like to see a property, contact Monticello real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
In addition to traditional single-family homes, in the area, you’ll find a number of country homes, farms and acreage, recreation properties, and investment properties as well.
In Q4 of 2021 (October - December), 45 residential homes sold in Monticello; this includes detached single-family homes, townhomes and condos. The average list price for homes in Monticello was $349,775 (compared to Tallahassee’s $283,003) and the average selling price was $342,363 (compared to Tallahassee’s $280,013). The average number of days homes sat on the market during this time period was 54.
In Monticello, during this time frame, all homes that sold were single-family homes. The least expensive was a 1,217 sq. ft. 2-bed, 2-bath home located on Hagan Street. While the most expensive home sold was a 3,346 sq. ft. 3-bed, 5-bath home on Aucilla Road, which sold for $1.2M.
In Q1 of 2022 (January - March), 36 residential homes sold. The average list price was $356,316 and the average selling price was $336,230, or approximately $20,000 under asking price. All but 2 of the homes sold were detached, single family homes (the others were townhouses). Square footage of the homes sold ranged from 775 to a whopping 8,679 sq. ft.
2 of the homes sold during Q1 2022 were more than $1M - one was on 7 acres and the other on 21 acres.
There are a number of reasons why residents love living in Monticello. The mild climate, natural beauty, and historic downtown area are appealing to those looking to escape city life. Citizens of Jefferson County take advantage of the beautiful countryside, filled with rolling hills, shady live oaks and tall pine trees.
Some of the popular activities include fishing, canoeing, hunting, bird watching, and biking. On weekends, Monticello’s historic downtown district is bustling with activities; it’s the perfect combination of country living and modern conveniences.
Click here to learn more about what it's like to live in Monticello, FL.
Explore our Instant Home Valuation tool to get an idea of what you home might be worth - no sign up or registration required!
.png)
Because of the area’s relatively low traffic, commute times are short, so many people choose to live in one city and work in another. At Coldwell Banker Hartung, we have real estate agents who live or work in Monticello as well as some of the nearby cities and towns, like Tallahassee, Crawfordville, Havana, Quincy, Thomasville, and Cairo.
Some popular neighborhoods in Monticello, Florida, are listed below:
Coopers Pond
Crooked Creek
Hiawatha Farms
The Sanctuary
Twin Acres
Just click the links above to view homes for sale in these Monticello neighborhoods. Please note, not all neighborhoods may have homes for sale at the moment, so be sure to bookmark this page and check back often if you want to buy a home in one of the subdivisions. To see all Monticello homes for sale,click here.
Use our free, easy-to-navigate search engine to look through all the neighborhoods & houses for sale in Monticello FL and the surrounding areas:
**This property is currently tenant occupied and requires advance notice for showings, but easy to show **Current lease is in effect through April 2025; lease details available upon request** Beautiful 1456 sq ft, 2000 year mobile home on 0.64 acres (2 parcels - Id 00-00-00-0360-0000-1611 + 00-00-00-0360-0000-1650). This home has been completely renovated with upgrades including a new metal roof, updated bathrooms, an updated kitchen with high end stainless steel appliances and new cabinets, luxury vinyl plank floors throughout, and new paint throughout. A great buy at $149,900!
Stately brick home in gated community of Hiawatha Farms~high elevation with 8.2 fenced pastoral acres perfect for horses~great split bedroom floorplan plus office~rocking chair front porch~large screen room overlooking backyard~3-car garage~HUGE walk in closet in master~wood-burning fireplace~separate cottage perfect for guests or teenagers~cottage also has large screened room~garage plus a covered bay for farm equipment or could be converted into horse stalls~this property consists of 3 lots totaling the 8.2 acres~homeowners association dues are $315 per lot
This immaculate home on over 5.5 acres is located in West Monticello & is only a short 4 minute drive outside of Leon County offering the convenience of being close to town while indulging in the pleasures of country living! This 3 bed/2 bath home sits on sprawling, flat land with gorgeous landscaping including many pecan trees and as an added bonus there is a huge 14x30 pole barn with a 12x13 air conditioned workshop with a full bathroom that suits all your storage and project needs! Inside the home you will find a spotless environment with grand vaulted ceilings, a beautiful brick gas fireplace, charming bay windows in the dining room and a functional layout that can support great entertaining! The kitchen has ample storage and plenty of prep space which also leads into a separate bar area with high top seating and a more relaxed vibe. The outdoor space is just as great with a large covered & screened patio with easy-breeze windows allowing a comfortable environment no matter the season. With a built in grill, this patio set up is ready for epic cookouts! The additional uncovered patio area is great when looking to enjoy the beautiful weather. The primary suite is large with a tray ceiling, dual sinks, a large soaking tub, and a great sized walk-in closet with built in storage. Other great features include a water filtration system, a 4 year old roof, newer HVAC unit, drip irrigation system, newly remodeled guest bathroom, newer kitchen appliances, & so much more! Do not miss this one of a kind property! *Seller cannot close before 12/31/24*
Amazing new construction 3 bedroom 2 bathroom by Nailed It Tallahassee LLC. Luxurious master suite, Kitchen made of dreams, this is a must see!
Private Country Estate on 14.74 acres. Two living areas ideal for multi-generational living or in-law suite. Upper level offers great room with fireplace and large spacious kitchen, formal living and dining and theater room. Four bedrooms 3 1/2 baths which includes two master suites! Lower lever has full roomy kitchen, great room, master bedroom , additional bedrooms, two full baths, library, sunroom, hobby room. Barn includes apartment/workshop/walk in cooler. Two car carport. Grounds include pond/creek/ grape orchard! Large deck and patio for entertaining. Planted pines, open fields. Great horse potential just 15 minutes to Tallahassee off of East Hwy 90.
Discover your dream home in the beautiful and serene, horse-friendly neighborhood of Hiawatha Farms. This private, gated community offers peace, tranquility and privacy while being conveniently located just 1 mile from I-10 and a quick 10 minute drive to Tallahassee. This spacious home offers the perfect blend of comfort and convenience, featuring a main house with open living spaces, modern kitchen with eat in dining, formal dining room, office space, very large master suite and cozy bedrooms, bonus/sun room, alongside a fully-equipped mother-in-law/guest cottage suite, with full kitchen, ideal for guests or extended family. Between the two homes sits a large and spacious covered pergola, perfect for outdoor entertaining. Located in a prime spot, you'll enjoy the tranquility of country living with easy access to city amenities. Don't miss this rare opportunity!
Come check out this cozy ranch style home in downtown Monticello! Walking distance to downtown for shopping and dining. Roomy kitchen with bar. Extra room could be den or dining. Built in bookshelves in living room . Very private backyard area in quite neighborhood.
NEW NEW NEW!In the world of real estate, the mantra "location, location, location" reigns supreme, and this stunning starter home epitomizes that ideal. As you step onto the charming front porch, you are greeted by elegant cedar columns that whisper of rustic charm, while the custom white pine shiplap ceiling above elevates the entryway to new heights of allure. Inside, the luxurious vinyl plank floors flow seamlessly through an open-concept design, leading you to a chef's paradise. The kitchen boasts high-end appliances that cater to every culinary need, complemented by custom soft-close cabinets and innovative slide-out shelving in the pantry, ensuring both functionality and style. The striking granite countertops, paired with an under-mount sink, are beautifully accented by a stunning subway tile backsplash that adds a contemporary flair. The spacious master bedroom serves as a serene retreat, featuring a walk-in shower that transforms daily routines into indulgent experiences. With floor-to-ceiling tile and a luxurious rain head, along with a detachable wand, this bathroom oasis is designed for relaxation. Convenience is key in this thoughtfully designed home, which includes a brand-new top-of-the-line washer and dryer located in the laundry room, just off the concrete back patio ideal for a mudroom setup after a day outdoors. Nestled in the desirable Lloyd area, this home offers the perfect balance of tranquility and accessibility. Enjoy the peace of rural living while being just 10 to 15 minutes from all the amenities of Tallahassee or Monticello, with Publix a mere 8 minutes away. This exceptional property checks all the boxes and is poised to captivate its new owners. Don t miss your chance to experience a lifestyle that merges comfort, style, and prime location.
Situated in the desirable Sanctuary neighborhood on a 1+ acre lot, this split floorplan combines both privacy and comfort, with an abundance of upgrades. The living room features crown molding, a coffered ceiling, built-in bookcases that beautifully frame the gas fireplace, and opens to a dream kitchen equipped with a large island with bartop seating, stainless appliances, including a gas range, and a thoughtfully designed butler's pantry. With no detail overlooked inside or out, the fenced backyard is open and spacious, with an area for gathering under the beautiful Live Oak, or grilling and entertaining on the back patio. Don't miss this move-in ready home, conveniently located to I-10, Tallahassee, and Monticello.
This breathtaking property checks ALL of the boxes! Please see associated docs as this home has so many features and details. The sellers have nick-named this home as "Monticello Yellowstone". Driving through the gated entry, you are greeted with Argentine Bahia Grass green pastures and most charming property. Five fenced and cross fenced pastures each with run in shelters, electric and water. Main house is 3200 square feet (Barn Apartment is additional 1400 Square Feet). Multiple level main main house is perfect for multi-generational living showcasing exposed beams, vaulted ceilings, bricked walls, and decked with tongue and groove hardwood ceilings. In-law/Guest Studio Suite also has private entrance with patio, mini kitchen, separate living space and walk-in shower. New 5000 square foot barn with 4 stalls, tack room, RV/Trailer parking. Barn also includes newly completed 2 bedroom / 1 bath apartment featuring spectacular 40 foot wood beam stretching across the entire living/ dining / kitchen space. Barn apartment has 40 foot deck overlooking pastures. As you walk through the property... enjoy many landscaped nooks, gravel walk ways, a large chicken coop, kids play area, above ground pool area (could be used for dog pen), rustic smaller barn used as a workshop, parking pavilion, and endless views of well manicured pastures. This is a must see property!
Nestled on the edge of serene plantation country, this charming 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home sits on a picturesque 2.83-acre lot with stunning views of rolling pastures filled with cattle and horses. Experience breathtaking sunsets from the comfort of your open living area, which boasts a wall of windows framing the vibrant evening sky. The home features a wrap-around deck, perfect for outdoor relaxation, and a fully fenced yard for privacy and security. Included on the property is a powered workshop, ideal for projects or storage, and a unique train car ready to be transformed into a studio or potential Airbnb rental. The expansive land offers ample space for starting your own personal farm, with rich, fertile soil to support your agricultural endeavors. Conveniently located near the historic towns of Monticello and Thomasville, and just a short drive from Tallahassee, this property combines peaceful rural living with easy access to modern amenities. The home also boasts a new roof (2020), an updated HVAC system (2018), and a personal well providing fresh, clean drinking water. Don't miss out on this unique blend of country charm and convenience!
Discover your dream home in charming Monticello! This nearly new, one-story gem boasts an open concept design with a split floor plan, perfect for modern living. The spacious primary bedroom offers a private retreat, while the screened-in porch invites outdoor relaxation. Impress guests with stunning 10-foot tray ceilings, granite countertops, and custom cabinetry. Enjoy the fenced yard for added privacy and peace of mind, and transfer switch installed for easy generator hook up. Minutes from historic downtown, your perfect blend of comfort and convenience awaits!
Rare 4 bedroom 2 bath home located 4 blocks away from downtown Monticello and walking distance to most of the popular restaurants and shops. Home features a spacious floor plan with hardwood floors throughout. Eminities include dining room, laundry room. a tankless hot water heater to conserve space. Also a spacious front porch. Backyard has an additional dwelling unit that could be in-law suite, work shop, or storage area. Home also has a large patio deck with built in brick barbecue grill with and additional wood burning brick fire pit away from the deck. This home won't take much to make it your dream home.
Stunning turnkey home on 5.5 acres on the highly sought after Gamble Road in Jefferson County, FL. Built in 2020, the bright and spacious 5 bedroom, 4.5 bathroom home is full of custom features! Downstairs features an open concept living space with beautiful kitchen, quartz countertops and island with seating. Kitchen and dining space flow into the living room, with French doors to the patio. Two downstairs bedrooms both have ensuite bathrooms. The downstairs primary suite offers a soaking tub, walk-in shower and spacious double vanity. Huge downstairs utility room even has it's own half bathroom! Upstairs you are met with three additional bedrooms. Two bedrooms have access to a jack and jill bathroom, with an additional guest bathroom off the landing and bonus space. The bonus nook would be perfect for storage, a small office, or adorable reading nook. The huge parking pad, with basketball hoop, is easily accessible from a side door with direct access to the kitchen. The 5.5 acres is mostly grassy open space with tons of room for outbuildings or recreation, plus a 50amp camper hookup! The gated driveway with woods along the property edges makes for the perfect amount of privacy. You'll have an easy 15 minute ride to Tallahassee as well 15 minutes to Monticello for any in town needs. Fresh paint, great appliances, beautiful floors... This home is a true must see! *All room dimensions and lot lines in photos are approximate, buyer is responsible for verifying exact dimensions.
Amazing new construction 3 bedroom 2 bathroom by Nailed It Tallahassee LLC. Luxurious master suite, Kitchen made of dreams, this is a must see!
Very nice home located on wooded acreage, all high and dry with great access to Tallahassee. Several outbuildings will remain on the property. They are good for storage, workshop, etc. Home and buildings are in very good condition. Showing is by appointment only, minimum of 24 hours needed to set up showing.
If you want SERENITY NOW ?, then come get it. This country living home is the one you want. With 5 bed, 3 bath home, less than 15 minutes from downtown Monticello. Five fully fenced acres with pastureland views, abundant wildlife to see. Bring the horses. Many upgrades included; whole home generator (2023), new plumbing through out (2023-2024), all three bathrooms completely remodeled (2023), HVAC (2023), two new water heaters (2023), all new floors (2023), 5 zone irrigation system (2023). See attached document for additional upgrades. Home comes completely furnished, items purchased in 2023/2024. Plus a Kubota BX 1880 tractor with mowing, front loader and tiller attachments included.
New Roof! New HVAC! Some repairs needed such as finishing half bath. Nearly a half acre of stunning backyard on the lake with outbuilding and shed for picnics and gatherings. Enclosed carport increases living/gathering space inside! So much opportunity here!
*Short Sale 3rd Party Approval Required* Main House 3Bdrm 2Ba w/attached Apartment/2Bdrm 1Ba In-Law Suite w/Kitchen, Living Area, Private Entrance & separate Driveway. Single Family Home, One Home w/Apartment as Rental, or Multi-Family/Generational Living. Corner Double Lot. Roof Replacement & HVAC (Main House) needed. Updates/Upgrades and General TLC needed. Buyer to verify all! All Terms Subject to 3rd Party Approval.
*Short Sale 3rd Party Approval Required* Main House 3Bdrm 2Ba w/attached Apartment/2Bdrm 1Ba In-Law Suite w/Kitchen, Living Area, Private Entrance & separate Driveway. Single Family Home, One Home w/Apartment as Rental, or Multi-Family/Generational Living. Corner Double Lot. Roof Replacement & HVAC (Main House) needed. Updates/Upgrades and General TLC needed. Buyer to verify all! All Terms Subject to 3rd Party Approval.
Adorable two bedroom, one bathroom house within walking distance to downtown Monticello. Recently renovated with new roof, fresh paint, new flooring, new windows, doors, & appliances, & bathroom. Ready to move in & eligible for 100% financing.
Check out this beautiful 2022 manufactured home sitting on 1.0 acres in the country. The home offers 4 bedrooms, 2 baths with a huge master suite. Within the the master suite you will find a sitting area, great for reading and drinking your morning coffee! The master bath offers a big soaker tub as well as a huge shower with dual shower heads. Outside of the master suite you will find the kitchen that offers lots of cabinets and counter space! This home is located on a paved road close to interstate 10 for quick access to Tallahassee. Also close to the historic city of Monticello for endless shopping and restaurants!
Nestled on 5.02 serene acres in the charming town of Monticello, this exquisite 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home boasts 2,620 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space. With a blend of traditional Craftsman details and modern amenities, this residence offers both style and comfort. The exterior features a combination of natural wood siding and stone accents, complemented by a welcoming front porch with classic Craftsman-style columns. Large, energy-efficient windows allow for abundant natural light while framing picturesque views of the lush landscape. Step inside to discover an open-concept living area with high ceilings, rich hardwood floors, and a cozy fireplace that serves as the focal point. The living room flows seamlessly into a spacious dining area, perfect for family gatherings and entertaining.
A rare find! Acreage with a pond, an immaculately maintained home, and an ideal location situated in west Jefferson County! A 1400 sq ft, 2002-construction home with Hardy-Board exterior and slab foundation. 2020 Roof and Gutters and 2021 New AC! An open-concept living/dining room floor plan with vaulted ceilings, a wood-burning fireplace, and plenty of windows to let in the natural light and enjoy the property views. A galley kitchen with bar, eat-in dining nook and added cabinetry for extra pantry space. The original flooring has been replaced with Pergo wood floors in the living/dining room and bedrooms, and tile in the kitchen, laundry room and both baths. A spacious master bedroom with a walk-in closet and updated master bath with tiled shower. A covered front porch for enjoying the property views and a back patio for grilling and/or entertaining. Property features in include: An absolutely beautiful, private, well-fed pond with separate, dedicated well and full of catfish, and 13+ acres of planted pines recently thinned in 2024, and ready to be cut in a few years. Also, a producing vegetable garden and several raised beds for those who enjoy putting their hands in the dirt. On well and septic. A separate pump-house with additional storage space, detached 2-car metal carport, a small storage shed with an overhang for lawn equipment, and a pole-barn, currently used for RV storage. New, gated driveway on Robert Thompson Rd. (paved/gov. maintained). Surrounded my agricultural and low-density residential property. Ideal for those looking for privacy and peace of mind, with the convenience of nearby shopping and/or a short commute. Perfectly situated between Jefferson and Leon counties. Less than a 15 minute drive to both downtown Monticello and East Tallahassee. Just (3.5) miles from I-10, FL-59 S./Gamble Rd., (6) miles from Hwy US-90, and (5) miles US Hwy 27.
Discover the McDonald-Guy House, a historic gem nestled in the heart of Monticello, FL. This 100-year-old southern treasure radiates timeless charm and enduring craftsmanship. Lovingly preserved, the home showcases an exquisite copper roof, original pine floors, and soaring 10-foot beadboard ceilings adorned with classic 10-inch baseboards. Step into the kitchen, where luxury meets functionality with Statuario marble countertops, a generous island for meal prep, and a sleek Samsung Bespoke gas range. The adjoining laundry area comes equipped with a washer and dryer, adding convenience to this elegant home. Outdoor living is a dream with a spacious 40-foot covered front porch perfect for soaking in the vibrant downtown atmosphere and a rear deck overlooking a beautifully landscaped, fenced backyard. Enjoy evenings around the brick firepit, surrounded by custom benches and lush greenery, all maintained by an automatic sprinkler system with a dedicated water meter. The property also includes a charming porte cochere, once sized for a Model T, now ideal for a golf cart or compact car. The rear guest suite, affectionately known as the "treehouse," offers serene views of the backyard, while additional features like under-home storage with spray foam insulation and a private outdoor shower enhance the home s appeal. With an AC unit replaced in 2020, this historic residence blends old-world charm with modern amenities. This unique home is a rare find come see it for yourself and make it yours today! All Reasonable Offers Considered!
