To see Monticello FL homes for sale, scroll through the carousel below.
For those looking to escape the hustle and bustle of Florida’s capital city, Monticello, Florida can be quite appealing. Monticello is located 26 miles from Tallahassee and 21 miles from Thomasville, GA. It is the largest town located in Jefferson County, with approximately 2,500 residents. One fun fact about Monticello is that there isn’t a single traffic light in the entire town!
If you have questions about homes for sale in Monticello, or the local housing market, read below, or contact an agent today:
At Coldwell Banker Hartung, we add new Monticello FL listings to our site every 15 minutes. We hire full-time real estate agents, to make sure buyers and sellers receive the uppermost care and attention during their real estate transaction. With our powerful search engine, you can filter by price, square footage, number of bedrooms, waterfront properties, pool homes, and more.
The median home value in Monticello, FL is $291,000. This is lower than the county median home value of $365,000. The national median home value is $277,796. The average price of homes sold in Monticello, FL is $291,000. Approximately 57% of Monticello homes are owned, compared to 29% rented, while 14% are vacant. Monticello real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale. Commercial properties are also available. If you like to see a property, contact Monticello real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
In addition to traditional single-family homes, in the area, you’ll find a number of country homes, farms and acreage, recreation properties, and investment properties as well.
In Q4 of 2021 (October - December), 45 residential homes sold in Monticello; this includes detached single-family homes, townhomes and condos. The average list price for homes in Monticello was $349,775 (compared to Tallahassee’s $283,003) and the average selling price was $342,363 (compared to Tallahassee’s $280,013). The average number of days homes sat on the market during this time period was 54.
In Monticello, during this time frame, all homes that sold were single-family homes. The least expensive was a 1,217 sq. ft. 2-bed, 2-bath home located on Hagan Street. While the most expensive home sold was a 3,346 sq. ft. 3-bed, 5-bath home on Aucilla Road, which sold for $1.2M.
In Q1 of 2022 (January - March), 36 residential homes sold. The average list price was $356,316 and the average selling price was $336,230, or approximately $20,000 under asking price. All but 2 of the homes sold were detached, single family homes (the others were townhouses). Square footage of the homes sold ranged from 775 to a whopping 8,679 sq. ft.
2 of the homes sold during Q1 2022 were more than $1M - one was on 7 acres and the other on 21 acres.
There are a number of reasons why residents love living in Monticello. The mild climate, natural beauty, and historic downtown area are appealing to those looking to escape city life. Citizens of Jefferson County take advantage of the beautiful countryside, filled with rolling hills, shady live oaks and tall pine trees.
Some of the popular activities include fishing, canoeing, hunting, bird watching, and biking. On weekends, Monticello’s historic downtown district is bustling with activities; it’s the perfect combination of country living and modern conveniences.
Click here to learn more about what it's like to live in Monticello, FL.
Explore our Instant Home Valuation tool to get an idea of what you home might be worth - no sign up or registration required!
.png)
Because of the area’s relatively low traffic, commute times are short, so many people choose to live in one city and work in another. At Coldwell Banker Hartung, we have real estate agents who live or work in Monticello as well as some of the nearby cities and towns, like Tallahassee, Crawfordville, Havana, Quincy, Thomasville, and Cairo.
Some popular neighborhoods in Monticello, Florida, are listed below:
Coopers Pond
Crooked Creek
Hiawatha Farms
The Sanctuary
Twin Acres
Just click the links above to view homes for sale in these Monticello neighborhoods. Please note, not all neighborhoods may have homes for sale at the moment, so be sure to bookmark this page and check back often if you want to buy a home in one of the subdivisions. To see all Monticello homes for sale,click here.
Use our free, easy-to-navigate search engine to look through all the neighborhoods & houses for sale in Monticello FL and the surrounding areas:
The cutest park model home on 3.43 acres partially cleared! This 1 bed 1 bath is a must see! It even has a loft for the kids to play in! A huge new 24x36 pole barn with a 12x36 covered lean to; with a 12x12 enclosed area, 16x12 laundry shed, and a RV hookup (electricity not connected). Property is located down a quaint little paved road on the outskirts of Monticello, just 5 minutes from I-10. Must have 24 hours notice for showing. Owner occupied with dogs. Must have pre-qual for showing. Showings preferred to be scheduled on weekends or late evenings as owner works from home. Additional interior photos coming soon
TURN-KEY-READY This 3 bedroom, 2 bath house has been fully renovated! A welcoming open-concept living/dining area adjoins the spacious, modern kitchen. The kitchen boasts new soft-touch close cabinetry, a large island, a pantry, granite countertops, and all new appliances. Through the kitchen, theres a separate mudroom, laundry, and rear entry with additional storage opportunities. The master bedroom with en suite features a double vanity, walk-in shower, garden tub, and separate water closet; plus a generous walk-in closet. Fresh bedrooms flank the guest bath, fully updated with a new tub, vanity, tile, and fixtures. Conveniently located 2.5 miles North of historic, downtown Monticello with easy access to Tallahassee, FL and Thomasville, GA. Additional updates include: New HVAC, new hot water heater, updated electrical and plumbing, new modern lighting, new vinyl plank flooring throughout, new 6-ft privacy fence, new paint inside and out, with new doors and hardware throughout.
Beautiful All Brick Home On 3 Acres In Highly Desirable Hiawatha Farms! Gated Community Providing Privacy and Security, This Home Features 5BR/3BA, Office Area, Wood Floors, Large Kitchen with Breakfast Nook and Corian Counters, Separate Living, Dining and Family Rooms, Fireplace, Large Laundry Room with Bonus/Storage Room Attached, Big Master with Deluxe Bath, Covered Patio and More!! Perfect Home for Entertaining, Guests and Large Family!!
STUNNING NORTH FLORIDA HOME! Walk into the "new home" smells with this amazingly renovated 4 bedroom 2 and half bath house. Brand new appliances, granite counter tops, freshly painted inside and out, and concrete driveway are all sported throughout the house. More additions include a new AC Unit, modern lighting, soft close cabinetry, and so much more. This beautiful residence is nestled on a corner lot just walking distance to the Jefferson County Park and Recreational Fields and three miles from Historic Downtown Monticello.
This property checks all the boxes! Here is a magnificent, brick, farmhouse which is the centerpiece of this 4.05 acres tucked away, between Monticello, FL and Tallahassee, FL. Live, work and play in this incredible, 4 Bedroom home with 2.5 baths on a corner lot. In addition to the basics you have a jumbo, 26x29 double car garage (has 806 sq. ft.) and 16x28 open deck which overlooks the beautiful acreage of the backyard. Master suite has walk in closet and barn wood laminate flooring throughout. Oversized laundry/pantry with half bath plus brick fireplace, well water and circular paved driveway. Lives large and has the natural ambience of joy, happiness and love that is hard to emulate these days. No HOA. Appointment requested. Proof of funds or Prequalification required.
Brand new construction in quiet, upscale development. Home qualifies for USDA financing. Construction completion should be the end of March. Picture is from a previous model.
Like New! Barely lived in 2020 Home in sought-after Crooked Creek Subdivision! Easy commute to Thomasville and Tallahassee with the small-town charm of Monticello! This beautiful 3/2 is on a great lot with a fully fenced back yard. This house is upgraded to include but not limited to features such as black stainless steel appliances, recessed lighting, vaulted ceilings, and granite countertops, with a stunning kitchen island. Three spacious bedrooms with generous closets and an oversized closet in the Master! An amazing screened in back porch. A great place to enjoy your morning coffee and enjoy the peaceful surroundings. Spacious two car garage. This home is a must see in Monticello!
All Brick Home on large corner lot ( .45 ac) in Lovely Monticello Florida! This handy man special has a newer metal roof and seller is giving a $ 6,000 credit for flooring or closing costs etc. to buyer with acceptable offer. Square footage doesn't include 19x10 Sun porch that can could be heated and cooled..18x13 covered porch , fenced yard and 16x10 shed that is included in sale. Sold as is with right of inspection. Three bedrooms one and one half baths. $176,000 .Public sewer being installed in the next year.
Situated on 5 acres of a Pecan Orchard this 2300 sq foot custom built pool home will not disappoint. 3 br and 2 1/2 baths with an office above the garage, a pole barn and a workshop allows the new owner to bring all of their toys and tools. Located just outside of Historic Monticello you are close enough to town but also get the luxury of living on a beautiful acreage homesite. Please allow 24 hours notice for showings.
Want to live out in the woods? Look no further! This is a very well maintained 3/2 2007 "Home by Destiny" doublewide mobile home with a new roof, on 2.18 ACRES. DEER AND TURKEY FEED RIGHT IN THE YARD. The property has been partially cleared, is partially-fenced with an a gate, and has 2 outbuildings and a wood shed between Tallahassee, FL and Valdosta, GA. Must love isolation, dirt roads and zero neighbors.
New construction builds in quiet and quaint Crooked Creek Subdivison! Conveniently located off of 90E, minutes from Historic Downtown Monticello. Commuting to Tallahassee or Thomasville is a breeze! Local parks, quaint shopping, makes this neighborhood a gem to call home. Highlights of builder specs are as followed: - 1883sqft - 3 bedrooms - 4th room could be used as an office or bonus room - 2 full baths - Tray ceiling in living room - LVP throughout - Tile in master/guest bath - Solid wood cabinets - Granite countertops - Barn door to 4th room - Separate laundry & mud room - Wood fireplace - 2 car garage - Split floor plan & open concept!
New Construction by Nailed It Tallahassee LLC. GOING UP NOW COMPLETION SET FOR END OF MARCH! Beautiful 3 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom home on large .57 acre lot! Stainless Steel appliances, beautiful finishes. PICTURES ARE OF PREVIOUS HOME!
Beautiful cypress log home on over 14 acres (2 lots) with more than 120 pecan trees in peaceful Hunter Ridge located in Monticello. Step into this well maintained custom 3 bedroom, 3 bath home that includes Pella windows providing plenty of light with beautiful views of the pecan grove, a loft, laundry room, wood burning fireplace, vaulted ceilings, custom cabinetry, walk-in closets, and plenty of room for storage. The sq. footage does not include the loft or a portion of the laundry room. The house includes a 1-car garage that is deep enough for two cars, a 2-car carport, and a 1,131 sq. ft. walk-out basement/workshop with a full bathroom, and double doors and windows looking out to the backyard.
More pictures coming soon. Renovation project started. The Alpha Foundations warranty will transfer to the new owner. Roof is solid and HVAC worked well before it was disconnected. There is a new septic system installed on the east side of the house and the moisture and fungus under the house has been addressed. Electric is turned off at the panel. Plumbing is not connected. This charming diamond in the rough is looking for mostly finishing touches. There is a potential to turn this into a 2/2 with an office. House needs drywall and flooring, tubs, sinks, kitchen appliances, and paint. Located in the community of Loma Alta in Jefferson County, this home is approximately 3/4 of a mile from the Monticello Courthouse. Built in 1948, this home has a carport, wood deck and generous backyard that is partially wooded. The lot is bigger than it looks and there is a potential hidden oasis behind the trees. There is a ton of potential here for the future owner. There is no HOA and home is conveniently located on E Washington.
New Year, New Home! This Charming Home has been renovated from top to bottom! Spacious 4 bedroom/2 bathroom home with Open concept eat-in kitchen and an island that views into the living room. The Kitchen is Airy and Bright with all new appliances and new custom kitchen cabinets, modern tile backsplash and ample countertop space, an area perfect for entertaining. There is also a Large 12x4 kitchen pantry and a nice sized interior laundry room. Attractive wood laminate plank flooring runs throughout the living spaces. The Split floorplan features 3 bedrooms and lovely hallway bathroom on one side of the home, then a large private master bedroom suite is on the other side of the home. There is a Huge walk-in Closet in the master bedroom as well as a new and modern bathroom. As you step outside into the backyard there is a patio with pergola overhead, perfect for backyard barbeques on those warmer Summer days. This is one you do not want to miss!
Gorgeous brand new construction on half acre or more! One story split floorplan with large master suite. Granite countertops with custom cabinetry. Ample living space and open concept with 10' trey ceilings. 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths and huge master shower. Fiber cement siding and architectural shingles. 185 total square feet of outside sitting space. Large 2 car garage. We have some homes in progress and some that have not even been started. No matter your timeframe, we can accommodate. Photos are of previous built home. Estimated completion date is 04/31/2023.
Adorable, 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom home is move-in-ready! Fully renovated from top to bottom with new roof and laminate flooring throughout. Vaulted ceiling in living room adds spacious feel. The kitchen has been beautifully redesigned. Must see to appreciate! Owner occupied. Showings by appointment only.
Gorgeous brand new construction on half acre or more! One story split floorplan with large master suite. Granite countertops with custom cabinetry. Ample living space and open concept with 10' trey ceilings. 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths and huge master shower. Fiber cement siding and architectural shingles. 185 total square feet of outside sitting space. Large 2 car garage. We have some homes in progress and some that have not even been started. No matter your timeframe, we can accommodate. Photos are of previous built home. Estimated completion date is 04/31/2023.
Gorgeous brand new construction on half acre or more! One story split floorplan with large master suite. Granite countertops with custom cabinetry. Ample living space and open concept with 10' trey ceilings. 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths and huge master shower. Fiber cement siding and architectural shingles. 185 total square feet of outside sitting space. Large 2 car garage. We have some homes in progress and some that have not even been started. No matter your timeframe, we can accommodate. Photos are of previous built home. Estimated completion date is 04/31/2023.
New 3BR/2BA home, 1680 sqft located in the heart of Monticello!! Open and spacious floor plan. Large family room & kitchen. Energy efficient home featuring spray foam insulation, double hung/double pane windows, steel exterior doors and energy efficient appliances. Master bedroom features large ensuite shower. walk-in closet and access to a deck, perfect for morning coffee or reading a book. 2- car carport with ample storage above. City water & sewer less than 1 mile from Courthouse.
This is a lovely home which was once a hunting cabin. Fully furnished with extras. carpet is a bit worn but owner will offer $ to replace. Two bedrooms and two baths.
Gorgeous, move-in ready farm on 79 acres MOL in Jefferson County, FL, with the potential to purchase additional acreage (3 Lee's Farm North is also for sale - video shows combined property)! If you have been looking for your new rural homestead with plenty of room for every type of farming, 3 Lee's Farm South is the ideal choice. You won't find the level of diversity, amenities and beauty in any other North Florida farm on the market. This land is absolutely stunning, from the pasture and pond, to the natural timber, to the historic renovated farmhouse. 3 Lee's Farm South boasts a variety of land types, and comes complete with a recently renovated 3/1 farm house and tons of useful improvements. The land is mostly flat, with the majority of the property in useable uplands consisting of pastureland (15 acres), planted pine (9 ac) and natural pine and hardwood timber. There is also a 1/2 acre fish pond. The pasture is fenced and cross fenced and is cattle and horse ready - smaller pens near the house have also been used for goat and sheep. Hunting in the area is some of the best in Florida with strong deer and turkey populations. Property improvements include an updated 3/1 farmhouse with 1,150 sq. ft. of heated and cooled space, pole barns (25x50), one enclosed shop building (26X30) and even a newer 16x24 small animal milking facility that has been used for goat milk processing. Water runs to almost all of the buildings, and all the barns have power. There are also water lines and watering troughs throughout the property. The property is ready for you to move in and start your own farming operation. The property is located in Jefferson County, FL just a few minutes from Monticello, and is just a short drive to Tallahassee. Note that this farm is part of a property split. 3 Lee's Farm North is also available as a separate purchase. Video shows both farms together.
Nothing better! Coopers Pond neighborhood, quiet location conveniently on US-19, less than 5 minutes from Historic Downtown Monticello. Minutes from I-10 and US 90, making commuting to Tallahassee or Thomasville a breeze! Local parks, quaint shopping, makes this neighborhood a gem to buy new or build custom! Highlights of builder specs are as followed: - 1762sqft - 4 bedrooms - 4th room could be used as office w/closet, bedroom or bonus room - 2 full baths - Vaulted ceiling in living room - LVP throughout - Tile in master/guest bath - Solid wood cabinets - Granite countertops - Barn door to 4th room - Separate laundry & mud room - 2 car garage - Split floor plan & open concept! Pictures and updates coming soon! Follow @tiffanykasdorf.realtor
Nothing better! Coopers Pond neighborhood, quiet location conveniently on US-19, less than 5 minutes from Historic Downtown Monticello. Minutes from I-10 and US 90, making commuting to Tallahassee or Thomasville a breeze! Local parks, quaint shopping, makes this neighborhood a gem to buy new or build custom! Highlights of builder specs are as followed: - 1762sqft - 4 bedrooms - 4th room could be used as office w/closet, bedroom or bonus room - 2 full baths - Vaulted ceiling in living room - LVP throughout - Tile in master/guest bath - Solid wood cabinets - Granite countertops - Barn door to 4th room - Separate laundry & mud room - 2 car garage - Split floor plan & open concept! Pictures and updates coming soon! Follow @tiffanykasdorf.realtor
Nothing better! Coopers Pond neighborhood, quiet location conveniently on US-19, less than 5 minutes from Historic Downtown Monticello. Minutes from I-10 and US 90, making commuting to Tallahassee or Thomasville a breeze! Local parks, quaint shopping, makes this neighborhood a gem to buy new or build custom! Highlights of builder specs are as followed: - 1762sqft - 4 bedrooms - 4th room could be used as office w/closet, bedroom or bonus room - 2 full baths - Vaulted ceiling in living room - LVP throughout - Tile in master/guest bath - Solid wood cabinets - Granite countertops - Barn door to 4th room - Separate laundry & mud room - 2 car garage - Split floor plan & open concept! Pictures and updates coming soon! Follow @tiffanykasdorf.realtor
